On Friday night, I went to see “Guys and Dolls: the Musical”, at the Capitol Theatre, Sydney. My brother, sister and I had grown up with “Guys and Dolls”, the movie, starring Frank Sinatra, Marlon Brando and Jean Simmons. It has always been one of my favourite movies- great songs, costumes, and comedy- and Frank Sinatra’s voice is stunning. We have all easily seen the movie atleast 50 times.
So when we went to see the musical, I had high expectations…..perhaps, a little too high, as I don’t think anyone could match up to Frank Sinatra’s voice.
Gary MacDonald played Nathan Detroit (Sinatra’s character), and what he lacked in voice (which was a lot), he made up for in comedy. While I first thought that perhaps they could’ve chosen a better person to play this character, as my sister said, then everyone would still be comparing them to Frank Sinatra. This way, I guess they wanted the audience to forget about comparing the singing, and more just about the acting.

Marina Prior played Miss Adelaide, exceptionally well. I went there expecting her to play Sara Brown, mainly because of the high note range in the songs that are sung by this character, however Marina made the character of Adelaide her own.
Lisa McCune actually played Sara Brown. I was very surprised by her singing capability- as I had never seen McCune in other musicals (although I know she has been in them before). I really enjoyed her drunken state in Havana- very funny!
Ian Stenlake played Skye Masterson, exceptionally well. Actually I much prefferred him than Marlon Brando’s version of this character. For one, Ian can sing! And its a great voice!
The suprise performance was Shane Jacobson- he played Nicely Nicely Johnson. At the start of the show, I think he had to warm up a little, but then when he sung “Sit Down You’re Rocking The Boat” towards the end, he was fantastic! Who ever thought that Kenny could sing!?!

Overall, to begin with, all I could keep on doing was comparing the musical to the movie- and it was quite annoying, but as the script started to change, the songs started to change, and I got more involved in the musical. I liked it how they deliberately changed sections, they added bits here, they took off there.
By the time they were half way through the first act, I was really enjoying it, and I had stopped comparing. My favourite scene was when Sky and Sara are in Havana, Cuba. Great dancing, costumes, comedy, songs. As well as the “Luck Be A Lady” scene with all the men in the sewer- great dancing! I think Ian Stenlake and Shane Jacobson stole the show really, with Marina coming next.
in the end I really did enjoy it- and it has made me want to watch all of my musical movies again, and start thinking about new designs to create inspired by the costumes!